"It was a dark and stormy night..."--remember Snoopy's famous one-liner that was going to begin his epic, but ever-elusive mystery story? Perhaps you know how Snoopy feels, perched atop his doghouse, typewriter silent, creative juices dried up. You've got that mystery story brewing in your brain. But where to begin? Well, my friends of the Omschool, here are mystery story writing prompts and suspense and horror fiction story starters to get you out of the doghouse and writing those mystery stories.
Teachers and homeschool parents, use these for creative writing lessons for Writers Workshop activities, National Reading Month (March) and NaNoWriMo (November). Write out mystery story writing prompts on the board and let students go writing their works of horror fiction. And now for the mystery and horror fiction creative writing lesson plans.
Horror Fiction Writing Prompt: What was in the Wishing Well "I hated drawing water from the dank, bug-infested well house to begin with. When the bucket came up heavier and more slowly than usual, I sensed that something was wrong. But I was totally unprepared for what followed...
Mystery story writing prompts: The Curio Shop Enigma "I hadn't remembered seeing the old curio shop on that street before, but the elderly gent was outside to peddle his wares and beckoned me in. When I returned the next day with my brother, shop and shopkeeper had gone. We asked an old-timer passing by where it was. 'That shop?' he declared, "why it ain't been around for 50 years!"
Mystery story starters: The Smell in the Attic "We always kept the attic trap door locked and no one ever went up there. One day as I passed, I smelled an oddly familiar smell, that I hadn't smelled since I was little. The odor got stronger, until finally I opened the door. As I went up the rickety steps, I got the shock of my life.
Mystery story starters: The Missing Picture Puzzle "I loved to look through our old family photos. One day, I noticed that a certain picture had been removed, no, not just removed, but viciously hacked out of the album. I asked the whole family and no one seemed to have taken it. Was someone hiding something?"
Horror fiction scary story starters: The Walled-Up Room "Tearing down a wall to build an addition to our home, I discovered a small narrow room hidden between the walls. It appeared to have been boarded up decades ago and what was in it gave me the fright of my life."
Horror genre creative writing lessons: The Thing in the Pond "For years, I've visited a pond in the woods near our house. Recently I saw something in the bottom. And it was more than sand, rocks and a few fish and turtles. Something much, much more..."
Mystery story starters and writing prompts: The Not-So- Prank Caller "We thought the odd phone calls were just pranks by some local kids. Until the caller asked me something really creepy. 'Did anybody ever find where you buried the body?"
Mystery story starters: The Letter from Yesterday "The envelope that came in the mail looked really elegant and I was hoping that it was an invitation to a party. It was an invitation...for a party dated, July 30, 1927."
Mystery story writing prompts for creative writing lessons: The Long-Gone Boy "We were all playing in our fort by the creek. A tall thin boy with dark eyes and long hair appeared silently from the woods. He came out every day for two weeks but he never said a word. Then he disappeared again, but returned with something terrifying..."
Horror genre scary story starters: What the Cat Brought Home "My cat likes to bring home an odd assortment of creatures. Not that he kills them. I think they are his friends. One day the cat brought home a "friend" the likes of which I've never seen before in my life and I doubt that I ever will again."
You can take these mystery story starters in any direction you want. It might be that what appears so creepy turns out to have a logical if strange explanation. The thing in the pond, for example might look like a dead body but turn out to be a statue thrown there because it showed signs of being alive. Or, what seems harmless, might be extremely terrifying and dangerous. It might be supernatural or natural. The thing in the well might be a ghostly specter or an unusual species, never seen in that area.
The important thing is to avoid overused themes and to be as creative as possible. The Book Seller's Enigma is not an unusual plot device. But you might use it to write a story in the style of Three Investigators or M.R. James in which the shop had been entirely recreated for the character to see and then torn down the next day. The "old-timer" doesn't just happen to be there. He's planted to confuse, to cover up an illegal operation in stolen artifacts. Or, like an M.R. James story, it has a sinister and ghostly explanation.
It's okay to emulate other authors, especially older ones, but don't plagiarize. And don't just change names and a few detail. That's plagiarizing too in that you're stealing intellectual property rights to the idea. To emulate is the write in the style of, not the content of an author.
Picture is our cat Mordecai who would bring home friends if he was allowed outside.









